The Texture Argument Settles Itself on the Back Label

The most common complaint in the one and two-star reviews is some version of "this is Vaseline." Zoe Ann Greenway wrote that it is "just petroleum jelly with an orange colour and the smell and feel of petroleum jelly." A two-star buyer put it more bluntly: "I'd rather get one of the other sprays than coat myself in petroleum jelly."

Flip the tub over and the ingredients list doesn't argue back. Petrolatum sits right at the top, followed by mineral oil and paraffin wax, then fragrance, vitamin E and beta carotene, which is where the orange tint comes from. So the sceptics aren't imagining things: this is an old-school, petrolatum-based basting butter, not a light modern lotion. That base is also exactly why it does what fans love. It's what makes the formula water and sweat resistant for swimming and poolside lounging, and it's why so many reviewers mention coming home with noticeably softer, smoother skin.

The real disagreement is about expectations. Buyers hoping for a fast-absorbing cream feel ambushed by the grease. Julia, who gave it three stars, found it "very greasy and doesn't seem to sink in at all," though she still called it a big pot for the money. Meanwhile Matt Bailey insists it "isn't greasy and washes off hands well once applied." Our take after reading the full spread: it is greasy, unapologetically so, and how you feel about that decides your star rating before the tan even develops. Malibu says the beta carotene works by encouraging the skin's dark pigment to the surface while you sunbathe, and the butter texture is simply the delivery vehicle.

Featured

15% OFF*Limited offer

One Sunday. A week of food, sorted.

23 high-protein recipes, cycle-synced for women who lift.

23 recipes · 60-page PDF · Instant download

£19.20 £16.32

See it on Etsy→

*Seller's discount on Etsy - may end at any time.

The Tan Itself: Two Shades Darker in an Afternoon, or Nothing at All

When this butter works, the reviews read like testimonials for something twice the price. Chloe, a 33-year-old with blonde hair and fair skin, had spent years tanning easily on her arms and chest while her legs stayed stubbornly pale. Her review: "I received it an hour ago - and my legs are already 2 shades darker after sitting in the garden!!!" Linda Logan reported a visible tan from a warm-but-not-hot session in her own back garden. Vikki, who says she has bought plenty of accelerators over the years, rates it the best she's used. Erika Short summed up the majority experience: "I got tanned so fast but make sure to also use sunscreen."

In our sample of 100 recent reviews, 66 were five stars and the average sat at 4.0, slightly below the listing's overall 4.4. The gap comes from a vocal minority who saw no acceleration whatsoever. Sylvie's entire one-star review reads: "Not fast at all." Another buyer reported coming back "white as a ghost," and a few others noticed no boost over a normal lotion.

A pattern worth noting: several of the happiest reviewers, like Phil Wadsworth, recommend using it "when already brown for a deeper colour," and Ian rates it "great for using after you've got a base tan." The strongest results in the reviews come from people who tan reasonably well anyway and want to go deeper, faster. If your skin barely colours in the sun, this pot is more of a gamble, and the sensible move for very fair skin is to be cautious with sun exposure full stop.

SPF 0 Means Zero. Read This Bit Even If You Skip the Rest

This is the section that matters most, because the reviews prove buyers keep getting it wrong. Malibu's own wording is unambiguous: "This product provides no protection from the sun, please use appropriate Malibu Sun protection products." It is a tan accelerator, not a sunscreen. It is also explicitly not suitable for children.

Yet Rowan left a one-star review after discovering "the packaging label actually states that the product contains NO SPF," having believed from the listing they were buying SPF 50. Another reviewer mentions SPF 15, which suggests Amazon is pooling reviews across different variants of the Malibu range on this listing. Whatever the pot next to it says, the tub reviewed here is SPF 0, so double-check the variant in your basket before you buy.

The consequences of skipping sunscreen with this butter show up in the reviews. Ava's three-star warning is hard to forget: "Smells good burns bad. I'm writing this in warning and AGONY." A few reviewers also reported rashes, including one whose daughter reacted despite wearing SPF 50 underneath, so a patch test is sensible if your skin is reactive.

The experienced users have the routine down. Chloe applies factor 50 first, lets it absorb for 15 minutes, then layers the Malibu on top. Jo1970 does the same with a high-factor cream and reports good results with no burning. JEDI_N8 puts it "over top of normal spf" for a golden tan. That's the way to use this product: SPF underneath, butter on top, shade during peak hours. Malibu says as much on the tub with its "pair with SPF for safe sun care" line, and every happy long-term user in the reviews follows it.

Stains, Sheets and One Unexpected Downside: Flies

The grease has practical consequences beyond feel, and the reviews are refreshingly specific about them. Tidds found the residue "rubbed off onto my car seat on the way to the salon and bed sheet when sitting down to put shoes on." Several others mention marks on clothes, particularly light fabrics, and Kayleigh found she couldn't apply it in the morning before sunbed sessions because of the yellow residue it left. Malibu itself warns you to avoid contact with fabrics, which tells you the brand knows.

Then there's the wildlife issue. Sally Raymer used it once on holiday, "attracted flies, showered and left it at the hotel." The two-star Vaseline critic backs her up: "It's heavy and everything sticks to it. Flies, grass, the pages of your book." If you're tanning in a garden rather than on a breezy beach, consider yourself warned.

Getting it off takes a little strategy too. M OBrien, who otherwise loves the product after it let a lifelong sun-rash sufferer finally sit in the sun without itching, recommends working shower oil into dry skin before showering to emulsify the butter, then washing it away with a soft cloth. Application, by contrast, is simple: scoop it out, rub it in generously and evenly, and reapply after swimming or towelling, since even a water-resistant formula rubs off.

The Coconut Smell Everyone Mentions, and the Pots That Arrived Wrong

If there's one point of near-universal agreement, it's the scent. Malibu describes it as their world-famous tropical coconut, and the reviews back the boast. Janet R. says it has "that holiday smell," Matt Bailey calls it "amazing" and says it "smells like holiday," and Antonia describes the scent as "like a mini-vacation in a tub." Even several unhappy reviewers concede the smell is lovely on their way to one star.

Which makes the exceptions stand out. A handful of buyers received pots that were white instead of orange, had little or no scent, and felt like plain petroleum jelly. Sara Dickinson's arrived with a best-before date that had passed the previous July, and Rebecca Acton's looked used or returned. These reviewers suspected faulty or out-of-date batches, and given that the correct product is distinctly orange from the beta carotene and strongly coconut-scented, that seems the likeliest explanation.

The practical advice: check your pot the day it arrives. It should be orange-tinted, smell like a pina colada, and carry a date comfortably in the future. A couple of buyers reported trouble getting returns accepted on this item, so flag any dud with Amazon immediately rather than discovering it at the airport. For what it's worth on the quality front, each pot is made in England, and Malibu states the formula is clinically proven to be kind to skin and tested only on humans.

Our Verdict: A Cheap, Greasy, Gloriously Effective Holiday Staple, With Rules

For around the price of a meal deal and a coffee, this 300ml tub delivers what most buyers came for: a deeper, faster, longer-lasting tan, very soft skin and a scent that does half the holiday's work for it. The five-star majority is large and enthusiastic, repeat buyers stock up before trips, and one reviewer spotted the same product selling for several times the Amazon price in Spain.

But it's a product with rules. Rule one: it contains no sun protection at all, so wear proper SPF underneath, every time, and keep it away from children. Rule two: it's a petrolatum-based butter, so expect grease, protect your clothes and sheets, and budget a proper shower to get it off. Rule three: it works best deepening a tan on skin that already colours; if you burn before you brown, this isn't your shortcut. And if your skin is sensitive, patch test first, because a few reviewers reported rashes.

Accept those terms and it's an easy recommendation, which is why we've landed on 4.1 out of 5: marked down for the grease, the stains and the handful of dud pots, held up by results that some buyers had chased for years. Check today's price on Amazon, and while you're there, add a high-factor sunscreen to the basket. The happiest reviewers never use one without the other.